Culture and Self in South Africa: Individualism-Collectivism Predictions

Liberty Eaton, Johann Louw

The Journal of Social Psychology · 2000 · 211 citations · 15 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Collectivist cultures are associated with more concrete and interdependent self‑concepts, yet research on self‑concept in African cultures—despite their collectivist nature—has been largely neglected, as noted by prior studies such as Uleman et al. (1995). The study aimed to partially replicate cross‑cultural findings on abstract‑concrete and independent‑interdependent self‑construal dimensions within an African context. The authors surveyed South African university students using the 20 Statements Test and analyzed 155 protocols—78 from African‑language speakers and 77 from English speakers—through three coding schemes based on language as a proxy for cultural identity.

Abstract

Abstract People from collectivist cultures may have more concrete and interdependent self-concepts than do people from individualist cultures (G. Hofstede, 1980). African cultures are considered collectivist (H. C. Triandis, 1989), but research on self-concept and culture has neglected this continent. The authors attempted a partial replication in an African context of cross-cultural findings on the abstract-concrete and independent-interdependent dimensions of self-construal (referred to as the abstract-specific and the autonomous-social dimensions, respectively, by E. Rhee, J. S. Uleman, H. K. Lee, & R. J. Roman, 1995). University students in South Africa took the 20 Statements Test (M. Kuhn & T. S. McPartland, 1954; Rhee et al. ); home languages were rough indicators of cultural identity. The authors used 3 coding schemes to analyze the content of 78 protocols from African-language speakers and 77 protocols from English speakers. In accord with predictions from individualism-collectivism theory, the African-language speakers produced more interdependent and concrete self-descriptions than did the English speakers. Additional findings concerned the orthogonality of the 2 dimensions and the nature and assessment of the social self-concept.

References

15