Dynamics of large-scale structure and electron transport in tokamak microturbulence simulations

Abstract

The important issue of whether zonal flows or streamers are preferentially formed in plasma turbulence with electron gyroradius scale is studied based on a gyrofluid model of electron temperature gradient (ETG) driven turbulence. Results from three approaches are presented. It is analytically derived first that the secondary generation of different large-scale structures is determined by the spectral anisotropy of turbulent fluctuation in two-dimensional Charney–Hasegawa–Mima turbulence. This is verified subsequently using three-dimensional simulations of sheared slab ETG turbulence, which show that the magnetic shear governs the pattern selection. It is found that a weak shear favours the enhancement of zonal flows so that the electron transport is strongly suppressed. In contrast, radially elongated streamers are formed nonlinearly in stronger-shear ETG turbulence. Finally, three-dimensional toroidal ETG simulations show that streamers are excited in the linearly stable region along the field (i.e. good curvature region) through a modulation instability after initial saturation of ETG modes. Although the electron transport at the quasi-steady state becomes higher than the initial saturation level, which is dominated by fluctuations with a peaked spectrum, the averaged value is still low at around the gyro-Bohm level. Furthermore, it is shown that the enhanced zonal flows in weak shear ETG turbulence may be limited by a Kelvin–Helmholtz instability. Also, it is found that the electromagnetic effects reduce the generation of zonal flows and reverse the so-called Okawa-scaling of electron transport on the β dependence.