Journal of Economic Literature · 2010 · 475 citations · 87 references
Social SciencesEconomicsDevelopment EconomicsEconometricsLabor EconomicsEstimation TheoryExternal ValidityInstrumental VariablesNatural ExperimentsStatistical InferenceInstrumental Variables EstimationRandomized Experiments
Deaton (2009) and Heckman & Urzua (2009) criticize the recent surge in experimental and quasi‑experimental methods in economics, especially the use of instrumental variables, natural experiments, and randomized trials. The author argues that prioritizing internal validity and clarifying target populations has strengthened empirical economics and addresses additional concerns raised by Deaton and Heckman‑Urzua. The author finds that this shift has improved the credibility of empirical economic research. JEL codes: C21, C31.
Two recent papers, Deaton (2009) and Heckman and Urzua (2009), argue against what they see as an excessive and inappropriate use of experimental and quasi-experimental methods in empirical work in economics in the last decade. They specifically question the increased use of instrumental variables and natural experiments in labor economics and of randomized experiments in development economics. In these comments, I will make the case that this move toward shoring up the internal validity of estimates, and toward clarifying the description of the population these estimates are relevant for, has been important and beneficial in increasing the credibility of empirical work in economics. I also address some other concerns raised by the Deaton and Heckman–Urzua papers. (JEL C21, C31)
87
Statistics and Causal Inference
Paul W. Holland · Journal of the American Statistical Association · 1986 · 5.1K citations