BioEssays · 2013 · 56 citations · 19 references
Life SciencesBiochemistryMolecular BiologyGene ExpressionPost-translational ModificationRna ProcessingProtein SynthesisRna DecayRna InterferenceRna StabilityTransfer Rna FunctionTranslation RegulationPost-transcriptional Gene RegulationPost-transcriptional Gene SilencingSmall Interfering Rna ModificationsTransfer Rna FragmentsTransfer Rna In Stress ResponseTransfer Rna-derived FragmentsTrna AvailabilityTrna Modification Effects
Endonuclease-mediated tRNA fragmentation has been observed in many species suggesting functional importance for tRNA fragments. The size distribution of tRNA-derived fragments indicates the existence of mechanisms that protect tRNAs and their fragments from total degradation by exonucleases. Could post-transcriptional modifications be important for the controlled processing of tRNAs? ds, double-stranded; PTGS, post-transcriptional gene silencing; RISC, RNA-induced silencing complex; siRNA, small interfering RNA; tRNA, transfer RNA. Transfer RNAs (tRNAs) play a central role in translating genomic information. The question whether these ancient molecules can also serve other biological functions is intriguing and has been discussed previously 1. The combined evidence from many years of tRNA biology indicates that a common denominator for the involvement of tRNAs in processes beyond their mRNA decoding capacity is the cellular stress response 2. Cells respond to stress by decreasing global transcription and protein synthesis concomitant with increasing expression and translation of stress-induced gene products 3. Therefore, any change in tRNA availability will impact on protein synthesis rates, especially under stress conditions. The discovery of stress-induced tRNA fragments in many organisms was therefore interpreted as confirmation that tRNA degradation inhibits protein synthesis 4. Indeed, recent data support the notion that tRNA fragments can selectively inhibit protein synthesis by targeting the translation machinery 5. What is presently not clear is how tRNA fragmentation is initiated, its extent controlled and terminated. Here, we introduce the idea that tRNA modifications are crucially important for the control of tRNA fragmentation as well as for the potential biological function of tRNA fragments. tRNAs are the most abundant small non-coding RNA molecules (4–10% of all cellular RNAs). tRNA-derived fragments are produced by stress-released ribonucleases that cleave mature tRNAs resulting in defined 5′- and 3′-fragments 4. While other small non-coding RNAs (i.e. miRNAs, siRNAs, piRNAs) are transcriptionally controlled in a cell cycle-dependent, tissue-specific, or developmental fashion, tRNAs are ubiquitous and constantly expressed for protein synthesis to work. This suggests control mechanisms in order to avoid constant tRNA cleavage and interference with protein synthesis. Indeed, many observations indicated that only a fraction of mature tRNAs is cleaved during the stress response, leaving the total tRNA pool unchanged 4. This suggests the existence of mechanisms that protect against quantitative tRNA degradation during the stress response and indicates that a major impact of tRNA fragments on protein translation is unlikely. RNases acting on tRNAs belong to the RNase A, T1, and T2 families that hydrolyze single-stranded RNA without sequence specificity 6, 7. How their activities are regulated is not exactly clear. Sub-cellular sequestration has been observed for Rny1 in yeast (RNase T2 family) and for angiogenin in mammalian cells (RNase A-family) both of which cleave tRNAs under stress conditions. These nucleases are segregated from cytoplasmic RNAs through targeting to membrane-bound organelles (the vacuole in yeast) or by extra-cellular secretion (in the case of angiogenin in mammals) 4. While stress can release these endonucleases from their “confinement”, the sub-cellular re-arrangement of RNA-containing structures such as processing bodies (P-bodies) and their dynamic interactions with stress-induced structures (e.g. stress granules) indicates wide-spread use of compartmentalized control and function of RNA and RNases 8. Over 100 post-transcriptional modifications exist in tRNAs. In mammals, up to 20% of the nucleosides in cytoplasmic tRNAs carry modifications 9. At first sight, the four stems that provide the backbone of the tRNA “cloverleaf” structure are scarcely modified. Instead, many modifications can be found at the intersections between stems and in the “open” regions such as in D-loops, anti-codon loops, variable loops, as well as in T-loops (Fig. 1A). Most modifications occur non-randomly at conserved positions across diverse species, which implies their individual importance 10. The presence of tRNA modifications has mostly been studied and interpreted in the context of tRNA maturation. The present consensus is that some tRNA modifications facilitate tertiary structure stabilization, which translates into robust tRNA function, especially under conditions when fidelity of protein translation becomes rate-limiting. Yet, a biological role for most modifications remains still unknown 10. Since even scarcely modified (mitochondrial) or even unmodified (e.g. in vitro transcribed) tRNAs can contribute to protein synthesis 11, it follows that many tRNA modifications are not essential for tRNA function during protein synthesis. If so, why are tRNAs so heavily modified? tRNA modifications and tRNA fragmentation. A: Depiction of the tRNA clover-leaf structure with D-loop, anti-codon loop (AC), variable loop and T-loop. Positions of existing tRNA modifications, independent of their chemical nature, as they are occurring in lower and higher eukaryotes are indicated in black (adapted from 2, 9, 10). The 3′-addition of CCA is depicted in gray. The position of 5-methoxycarbonyl-methyl-2-thiouridine (mcm5s2U) at the wobble base (U34) of tRNAs that attract and are cleaved by cytotoxic endo-nucleases 6, 16, 17 is indicated in green. The position of 5-methyl-cytosine, which has been implicated in protecting various C38-containing tRNAs from endo-nucleolytic cleavage 18 is depicted in red. Abbreviations are used according to the Modomics database (http://modomics.genesilico.pl). B: Simplified depiction of the main tRNA-derived fragment categories that have been identified in a number of RNA sequencing experiments. Preferential cleavage in the open loop structure by T1, T2, and RNase A family endonucleases creates fragments with distinct length distributions. Cloning biases due to RNA modifications might be responsible for the under-representation of all existing fragment combinations. C: Depiction of the tRNA clover-leaf structure as in (A) with the positions of various 2′-O-methyl-modified nucleosides (Cm, Gm, Um) that exist either within loops or at the intersection of loop and stem structures in almost all tRNAs. RNA can act in an immune-stimulatory fashion. RNA is recognized by three types of immunoreceptors. Activation of Toll-like receptors (TLRs), protein kinase R (PKR), and RNA helicases (e.g. RIG-I) leads to the release of cytokines and gene expression changes. RNA nucleoside modifications can modulate these recognition mechanisms. Specifically, RNA methylation abrogates the activation of the innate immune system, which indicates that RNA modifications facilitate the distinction between self and non-self RNA 12. Importantly, a conserved tRNA methylation in the D-loop was shown to be sufficient to suppress tRNA-mediated immune stimulation in human cells 13. At least two canonical tRNA degradation pathways exist in eukaryotic cells. The first pathway is triggered by a loss of essential tRNA modifications and is mediated by the nuclear TRAMP complex. Poly-adenylation of hypo-modified tRNAs by TRAMP is followed by tRNA degradation in the nuclear exosome 14. The second pathway occurs both in the cytoplasm and in the nucleus and involves the loss of non-essentíal tRNA modifications. It has been termed “rapid tRNA decay” (RTD) because it acts at degradation rates that are similar to those of mRNAs 15. The existence of tRNA degradation pathways shows that cells have sensors to detect the absence of a modification and that detecting hypo-modified tRNAs leads to the removal of non-functional or potentially immune-stimulatory tRNAs in eukaryotes. In addition to the removal of dysfunctional tRNAs by degradation, the occurrence of specific tRNA fragments has been observed in many species suggesting coordinated or programmed cleavage of tRNAs. In light of the discovery that tRNA fragmentation increases upon stress exposure, an intriguing question is whether post-transcriptional nucleoside modifications could influence tRNA fragmentation. Could some modifications attract RNases to a specific position or could they block RNases? Evidence for both scenarios has been reported. For instance, bacteria specifically cleave their own tRNAs in a suicidal attempt to defend the population against infection by bacteriophages 6. In another example, the yeast Kluyveromyces lactis employs a “killer” endonuclease that attacks the anti-codon loops of a variety of Saccharomyces cerevisiae tRNAs, thereby inhibiting the proliferation of a non-self yeast species 16. In both cases, a modified uridine (5-methoxycarbonyl-methyl-2-thiouridine (mcm5s2U)) in the wobble position (U34) of the anti-codon of the targeted tRNAs is essential for endonuclease activity at this site 17 (Fig. 1A). These observations indicate that the modification status of tRNA nucleotides can specifically target endonucleases. In addition, recent experiments in Drosophila showed that anti-codon loop modification affects stress-induced endonuclease activities 18. Specifically, cytosine-5-methylation at position C38 reduced the cleavage of specific tRNAs during the heat shock response (Fig. 1A). While the molecular details of the interactions between RNases and tRNA modifications remain to be elucidated, these observations support the notion that specific tRNA modifications can affect tRNA fragmentation. While tRNA modifications can directly impact on the tRNA fragmentation process, the occurrence of long-lived and specific tRNA fragments raises the question whether modifications in “nicked” tRNAs or tRNA fragments provide protection from nucleases. The length distribution of observed tRNA fragments indicates four major tRNA fragment categories, which correlate with tRNA cleavage in the various loop structures (Fig. 1B). Since endonucleases cut single-stranded RNA, the resulting 3′- and 5′-ends will become accessible to cellular exonucleases. Generally, exonucleolytic degradation will be blocked by double-stranded (ds) RNA structures that are present as individual tRNA stems. In addition, it is conceivable that “nicked” tRNAs are unwound by RNA helicases leading to the separation of tRNA fragments. This would create bona fide single-stranded RNAs with open ends that are accessible to exonucleases. Importantly, small RNAs can be stabilized by the activity of a conserved enzyme, Hen1, which adds 2′-O-methyl groups to terminal nucleotides of siRNAs 19. In this respect, it is interesting that specific 2′-O-methyl-modified nucleosides (Cm, Gm, Um) exist in loop structures of almost all tRNAs (including bacterial tRNAs), which suggests the existence of stops to exonucleolytic degradation (Fig. 1C). Small RNA remodeling by trimming has been observed 20. Additionally, also base modifications can improve siRNA stability 21. These observations indicate that nucleoside modifications improve nuclease resistance of small RNAs and it remains to be seen whether tRNA fragments can be equally processed and stabilized. If length and stability of tRNA fragments could be controlled by nucleoside modifications, what would be the biological role of such fragments, especially under stress conditions? Evidence for a function of tRNA fragments beyond the inhibition of protein translation is still anecdotal. Surprisingly, RNA sequencing experiments have identified the association of tRNA fragments with core components of siRNA pathways. Various hypotheses have been put forward to rationalize this association. While most envision a specific role for tRNA-derived fragments in post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) 22, i.e. a similar function to siRNAs in interfering with translation of specific mRNAs, we speculate here that tRNA fragments could act as non-specific small RNA mimics that interfere with the function of RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC) components during the stress response. The correct function of siRNA pathways is of crucial importance for the targeting and degradation of exogenous mobile RNA-based elements as well as the regulation of endogenous mRNAs 23. Why and under which circumstances would it be advantageous to interfere with these pathways? Importantly, siRNA pathway mutants are mostly viable and can reproduce normally, which suggests roles for these pathways under non-laboratory conditions (such as stress). Stress causes the widespread re-organization of cellular RNA granules 8, which supports the idea of localized interactions between siRNA components and stress-induced factors. Two core components of siRNA pathways (Dicer and Argonaute-2; Ago-2) are nucleases that act on dsRNA. Their association with dsRNA is governed only by RNA structure but not sequence, allowing the dicing (Dicer) or slicing (Ago-2) of almost any dsRNA. Stress generates increased numbers of such dsRNAs, especially in the form of “nicked” tRNAs and tRNA fragments. Since Dicers and Argonautes can associate with tRNA-derived sequences 24, 25, it follows that specific stress conditions might favor such association. Ago-2 has been found in stress granules, which also correlated with decreased RNAi in human cells 26. In addition, Drosophila Ago-2 loading with specific small RNAs has been shown to increase after heat shock 27. These observations raise the possibility that stress-induced RNAs (e.g. tRNA fragments) could compete with dsRNA precursors (Dicer substrates) and siRNAs (Ago-2 effectors) for Dicer or Ago-2 binding, respectively. tRNA fragment abundance and length distribution (which might be controlled by their modification status) alleviates the need for sequence-specificity. Functionally, such tRNA-based competition might rapidly block the inhibitory effects of siRNAs on various mRNAs. This would facilitate the restarting of important cellular processes during the stress recovery (Fig. 2). Importantly, little is known about the mRNA targets of endo-siRNAs. There is, however, computational as well as direct evidence for mRNA targets that are involved in DNA and RNA metabolism including DNA repair enzymes and cell cycle regulators 28. Since stress-induced cellular damage has to be repaired before transcription and cell cycle progression commences, utilization of already transcribed mRNAs (i.e. de-blocking their siRNA-mediated repression) could be a rate-increasing step during the stress recovery. In this respect, it is noteworthy that AGO2 (also called eIF2C2) was originally identified as translational enhancer 29 and that under serum starvation conditions AGO2 is recruited to mRNAs, which facilitates their enhanced translation 30. tRNA association of Ago-2 might therefore be a molecular switch that changes a repressor into an activator (Fig. 2). Based on these speculations, the biological significance of tRNA fragmentation might not only be sought in protein synthesis inhibition but also in relieving specific siRNA-controlled mRNAs during the stress recovery. tRNA fragments compete with siRNA-loading during the stress recovery. Stress-induced tRNA fragmentation contributes to the inhibition of protein synthesis. tRNA fragments outnumber any specific cellular small RNA population. The promiscuous and non-specific association of “nicked” tRNAs and tRNA-derived fragments with siRNA pathway components (i.e. RISC) interferes with efficient processing (Dicers: precursor RNA to siRNA) and loading (Ago-2: siRNA that targets mRNA) of siRNAs (e.g. endo-siRNAs) into RISC. As a consequence, the translational repressor function (red shadow) of some RISC components (e.g. Ago-2) on existing stress-response transcripts is inhibited or parts of RISC (Ago-2) could even be switched to an enhancer function (green shadow). The competition of tRNA fragments with PTGS would thereby allow the fast-track translation of mRNAs that are crucially important for the recovery from stress-induced cellular damage. This work was supported by a grant from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft to M.S (FOR1082). Z.D. is a fellow of the HBIGS graduate program at the DKFZ. The authors have declared no conflict of interest.
19
Methylation as a Crucial Step in Plant microRNA Biogenesis
Bin Yu, Zhiyong Yang, Junjie Li et al. · Science · 2005 · 1.1K citations
Angiogenin-Induced tRNA Fragments Inhibit Translation Initiation
Pavel Ivanov, Mohamed M. Emara, Judit Villén et al. · Molecular Cell · 2011 · 1K citations · Full text
RNA methylation by Dnmt2 protects transfer RNAs against stress-induced cleavage
Matthias Schaefer, Tim Pollex, Katharina Hanna et al. · Genes & Development · 2010 · 773 citations · Full text