A resampling-based method for effort correction in abundance trend analyses from opportunistic biological records

Niklaus Zbinden, Marc Kéry, Guido Häfliger, Hans Schmid, Véréna Keller

Bird Study · 2014 · 11 citations · 30 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

<b>Capsule</b> Resampling data from biological records databases yielded abundance trend estimates better corrected for increasing observation effort.<b>Aims</b> To correct population trend estimates for the effects of annually changing observation effort in analyses of opportunistic data.<b>Methods</b> We developed a resampling-based abundance index for analysis of population trends based on opportunistic citizen-science observations. To correct for the huge recent increase in observation effort every year, we resampled (with replacement) a species-specific constant number of records from the data and computed our index. To validate our standardized index, we used counts from the national waterbird census as a benchmark.<b>Results</b> Over 22 winters (1991–2012), trend estimates based on resampled indices were substantially more similar to waterbird census-based trend estimates than were raw index-based trends. Raw index trends were off by 648% (se 72%) and typically overestimated trends, while trends computed from standardized indices were off by only 125–131% (se 12–13%) and over – and underestimated trends about equally frequently. Hence, our method of effort correction reduced the bias in trend estimates by a factor 5.<b>Conclusion</b> Our resampling method may be useful for improving trend analyses from collections of opportunistic biological records, as they become increasingly available, especially via the internet.

References

30