Environmental Science & Technology · 2010 · 1.1K citations · 34 references
Life SciencesEnvironmental SciencesLife Cycle AssessmentNutrient CyclingWastewater TreatmentAlgal BiotechnologyAlgal CultivationAlgal EcologyAlgal PhysiologyGreenhouse Gas ProductionPhosphorus CycleAlgal Biomass ProductionEnvironmental Life Cycle AssessmentEutrophicationEutrophication PotentialMunicipal Wastewater ManagementMunicipal Wastewater TreatmentWastewater-based Algal CultivationWastewater-based Cultivation
Algae offer high energy yields per area without competing with food crops, yet their life‑cycle environmental performance has not been compared with conventional crops. The study uses a stochastic life‑cycle model to assess algae production versus switchgrass, canola, and corn, and then expands the model to evaluate the benefits of coupling algae cultivation with municipal wastewater effluents. The model compares algae to terrestrial crops, explores offsetting algae’s burdens with flue gas and municipal wastewater, and examines how different wastewater sources can reduce upstream CO₂ and fertilizer impacts. Conventional crops outperform algae in energy use, greenhouse‑gas emissions, and water consumption, while algae only excel in total land use and eutrophication potential; however, integrating municipal wastewater—especially source‑separated urine—substantially lowers algae’s environmental footprint and can make it more favorable than terrestrial crops.
Algae are an attractive source of biomass energy since they do not compete with food crops and have higher energy yields per area than terrestrial crops. In spite of these advantages, algae cultivation has not yet been compared with conventional crops from a life cycle perspective. In this work, the impacts associated with algae production were determined using a stochastic life cycle model and compared with switchgrass, canola, and corn farming. The results indicate that these conventional crops have lower environmental impacts than algae in energy use, greenhouse gas emissions, and water regardless of cultivation location. Only in total land use and eutrophication potential do algae perform favorably. The large environmental footprint of algae cultivation is driven predominantly by upstream impacts, such as the demand for CO2 and fertilizer. To reduce these impacts, flue gas and, to a greater extent, wastewater could be used to offset most of the environmental burdens associated with algae. To demonstrate the benefits of algae production coupled with wastewater treatment, the model was expanded to include three different municipal wastewater effluents as sources of nitrogen and phosphorus. Each provided a significant reduction in the burdens of algae cultivation, and the use of source-separated urine was found to make algae more environmentally beneficial than the terrestrial crops.
34
Land Clearing and the Biofuel Carbon Debt
Joseph Fargione, Jason Hill, David Tilman et al. · Science · 2008 · 3.9K citations
Ethanol Can Contribute to Energy and Environmental Goals
Alexander E. Farrell, Richard J. Plevin, Brian T. Turner et al. · Science · 2006 · 2.8K citations
Life Sciences, Environmental Engineering, Environmental Sciences +17
Life-Cycle Assessment of Biodiesel Production from Microalgae
Laurent Lardon, Arnaud Hélias, Bruno Sialve et al. · Environmental Science & Technology · 2009 · 1.5K citations
Biodiesel production from heterotrophic microalgal oil
Xiaoling Miao, Qingyu Wu · Bioresource Technology · 2005 · 1.4K citations