Foamed Cement vs. Conventional Cement for Zonal Isolation—Case Histories

Kevin B. Kopp, Shawn Reed, Jay Foreman, Brian Carty, James Griffith

SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition · 2000 · 41 citations · 5 references

Concepts

Abstract

Abstract Data from six deep gas wells in Wyoming indicate that foamed cement outperforms conventional cement for zonal isolation. Two of the six wells were cemented across the production zones with conventional non-nitrified cements. These wells experienced outer-zone communication after the stimulation treatments. In the other four wells, the foamed-cement sheath provided zonal isolation even after the sheath was perforated and stimulation treatments were performed. The case histories described in this paper provide an opportunity to compare the performance of foamed cement to conventional cement on similar wells within a particular geographic area. Large-scale laboratory testing has shown that foamed-cement is ductile and can deform as casing is pressurized, but will not crack like non-nitrified cement. These test results were confirmed by the results obtained in the six case-history wells. In the first two wells that were cemented, the operator used the conventional high-strength, non-nitrified cement across the formations. Tracer tags on the stimulation treatment showed that zonal isolation was not achieved and that the stimulation treatment communicated between the high- and low-pressure zones. The operator elected to use foamed cement for the last four wells to help obtain zonal isolation. In these wells, the stimulation treatment remained in the zone, little fracture growth occurred outside the target formation, and communication did not occur between the high- and low-pressure zones. This paper provides details about the slurry design and job execution on the six case-history wells, and also presents the postjob analysis that verifies the conclusions.

References

5