Leisure Studies · 2000 · 198 citations · 24 references
Social SciencesSocial PsychologySociologyBehavioral EconomicsPhysical ActivitySport PsychologyFan StudiesLeisure ParticipationParticipation TrajectoriesSocial ParticipationSport ParticipationActivitiesActivities ParticipationLeisure BehaviorLeisure EngagementLeisure IdentityOut-group DerogationRecreational ParticipationUnrealistic Optimism
Stebbins’ profit hypothesis explains serious leisure when perceived benefits exceed costs, but it fails to account for continued participation when costs appear to outweigh rewards. This study adopts a social‑identity perspective to identify and demonstrate how four compensatory behaviours—ingroup favouritism, outgroup derogation, unrealistic optimism, and voice—support continued engagement in serious leisure. These behaviours are examined within football fandom to explain why participation persists despite apparent unrewarding conditions. The authors present a model of serious leisure participation grounded in these compensatory behaviours.
Stebbins (1992) has suggested that the 'profit hypothesis', whereby the perceived benefits of taking part in an activity exceed the perceived costs, can be used to explain continued engagement in serious leisure activities. This argument, however, fails to explain the continued participation in such activities where the costs to the individual seem to exceed the rewards. This paper adopts a social identity perspective to identify and demonstrate the role of four compensatory behaviours – in-group favouritism, out-group derogation, unrealistic optimism, and voice – in ensuring continued participation in serious leisure. Such behaviours are described in the context of one particular serious leisure activity – that of football fandom – to explain why engagement in such an apparently unrewarding activity is maintained. A model of serious leisure participation is presented based upon these behaviours
24
Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations
Henri Tajfel · Annual Review of Psychology · 1982 · 7.8K citations
Amateurs, professionals, and serious leisure
Choice Reviews Online · 1992 · 719 citations