Psychological Review · 1903 · 55 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesPsychologyExperimental PsychologyVisual PerceptionVisual PsychophysicsDiscrimination TestingLight PerceptionPsychophysicsReaction TimeVisual Discrimination
Professor Cattell in a very few pages opens up some interesting problems and presents a number of exceedingly suggestive and interesting considerations.After a brief r^sumd of criticisms of the generally employed psychophysical measurement methods, advanced in an earlier article (cf.American Journal of Psychology, Vol.V., pp.2S5-294), he proposes a new method of approaching the problem of measurement of the intensity of sensation, which is based on the measurement of the time occupied in perceiving a difference between two sensation intensities or qualities.The shade of gray which takes as long to discriminate from white as from black should, according to this scheme, be the gray which for consciousness is midway between white and black.The method may also be used for testing differences of sensibility.The experimental sections of the paper include first, a series of investigations in the discrimination of light intensities, carried out by means of a series of 211 shades of gray papers, using the method of average errors.The results show a decrease in the sensibility of discrimination, with the increase of the intensity of the stimulus, not however such a decrease as would satisfy Weber's Law, but rather a •decrease approximately in direct proportion to the increase of the square root of the stimulus.This is in accord with the hypothesis proposed in the above-mentioned article, viz., " The error of observation tends to increase with the square root of the magnitude, the increase being subject to variation whose amount and cause must be determined for each special case."The second section of the experiments investigates the differences in intensity as measured by the time of perception.The same gray cards were used.The results indicate that with the decrease of the difference between the intensities compared, a longer time is required to make the discrimination.This tendency is approximately uniform with the two observers, but as the writer himself remarks, the number of the experiments is quite inadequate to enable one to draw any very definite conclusions.