Transhumanism and Its Critics

Keith Bauer

International Journal of Technoethics · 2010 · 29 citations · 10 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Transhumanism is a movement that seeks to transform human nature through pharmacology, genetics, cybernetics, nanotechnology, and other technologies to enhance physical, sensory, cognitive abilities and extend lifespan. The author evaluates three arguments against transhumanism, arguing that they are unpersuasive, while also presenting two arguments that have merit. The analysis considers a justice argument about the distribution of benefits and burdens of enhancement technology and an argument questioning the assumption of an essential human nature that can be transcended.

Abstract

Transhumanism is a social, technological, political, and philosophical movement that advocates the transformation of human nature by means of pharmacology, genetic manipulation, cybernetic modification, nanotechnology, and a host of other technologies. The aim of this movement is to increase physical and sensory abilities, augment intelligence and memory, and extend lifespan. After providing some background on transhumanism, its philosophical heritage, and its goals, the author looks at three arguments against transhumanism, arguing that they are unpersuasive and should be rejected. This paper presents two arguments against transhumanism that have merit. The first argument is an argument from justice that addresses the distribution of benefits and burdens for funding, developing, and employing enhancement technology. The second argument examines a significant assumption held by many transhumanists, namely, that there is an essential “human nature” that can be transcended.

References

10