Science as Social Knowledge: Values and Objectivity in Scientific Inquiry

Marlene Mackie, Helen E. Longino

The Canadian Journal of Sociology · 1992 · 1.1K citations · 0 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Science is traditionally viewed as a value‑free, objective method for understanding the natural world. Longino argues that scientific methodology cannot eliminate social and cultural values, and proposes contextual empiricism—seeing science as a social process—to preserve objectivity while engaging methodologists and social critics. She develops contextual empiricism by analyzing feminist‑criticized research programs—such as human evolution, prenatal hormonal theories, sex‑difference cognition, and sexual orientation—to illustrate how socially laden assumptions shape data interpretation. Longino concludes that conventional accounts of scientific methodology fail to account for social and cultural values, demonstrating through case studies that such values shape data interpretation and that science must acknowledge its ideological underpinnings.

Abstract

Conventional wisdom has it that the sciences, properly pursued, constitute a pure, value-free method of obtaining knowledge about the natural world. In light of the social and normative dimensions of many scientific debates, Helen Longino finds that general accounts of scientific methodology cannot support this common belief. Focusing on the notion of evidence, the author argues that a methodology powerful enough to account for theories of any scope and depth is incapable of ruling out the influence of social and cultural values in the very structuring of knowledge. The objectivity of scientific inquiry can nevertheless be maintained, she proposes, by understanding scientific inquiry as a social rather than an individual process. Seeking to open a dialogue between methodologists and social critics of the sciences, Longino develops this concept of contextual empiricism in an analysis of research programs that have drawn criticism from feminists. Examining theories of human evolution and of prenatal hormonal determination of gender-role behavior, of sex differences in cognition, and of sexual orientation, the author shows how assumptions laden with social values affect the description, presentation, and interpretation of data. In particular, Longino argues that research on the hormonal basis of sex-differentiated behavior involves assumptions not only about gender relations but also about human action and agency. She concludes with a discussion of the relation between science, values, and ideology, based on the work of Habermas, Foucault, Keller, and Haraway.