American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology · 2003 · 164 citations · 18 references
EducationPediatricsSpeech-language PathologyChild DevelopmentCommunication DisordersPediatric Speech-language PathologyApraxia Of SpeechLanguage DisordersMotor Speech DisordersApraxia DiagnosisChildhood Speech DisordersDevelopmental Apraxia Of SpeechDifferential Diagnostic CriteriaMean Length Of UtteranceOral-motor DifficultiesSpeech Motor DisordersSpeech Pathology Diagnostics
The diagnostic criteria used to identify developmental apraxia of speech (DAS) have been controversial for decades, and many children are identified with this disorder despite difficulty distinguishing it from other speech acquisition disorders. The report examines the criteria used by 75 speech‑language pathologists to diagnose DAS. The authors surveyed 75 clinicians, collecting the characteristics they use to establish a DAS diagnosis. They identified 50 characteristics, but six accounted for 51.5% of responses, including inconsistent productions, general oral‑motor difficulties, groping, inability to imitate sounds, increasing difficulty with utterance length, and poor sequencing, underscoring the ambiguity of DAS diagnostic criteria.
The diagnostic criteria used to identify developmental apraxia of speech (DAS) have been at the center of controversy for decades. Despite the difficulty in determining the characteristics that differentiate DAS from other speech acquisition disorders, many children are identified with this disorder. The current report presents the criteria used by 75 speechlanguage pathologists to establish a diagnosis of DAS. Although 50 different characteristics were identified, 6 of these characteristics accounted for 51.5% of the responses. These characteristics included inconsistent productions, general oral-motor difficulties, groping, inability to imitate sounds, increasing difficulty with increased utterance length, and poor sequencing of sounds. These results are consistent with the general ambiguity of the diagnostic criteria of DAS and suggest that no single deficit is used among clinicians.
18