Planning versus Chaos in Clausewitz's<i>On War</i>

T. Michael Holmes

Journal of Strategic Studies · 2007 · 19 citations · 3 references

Concepts

Abstract

ABSTRACT Clausewitz laid great emphasis on the planned construction of war, but this idea has received little attention from his commentators, who generally attach far greater importance to what he said about the chaotic elements of war, in particular its interactive nature and the friction inseparable from its conduct. This article gives long-overdue recognition to planning as a dominant theme of On War. The essential point Clausewitz makes concerning interaction is not that the enemy’s responses are bound to disrupt our plans, but that our plans must aim to predict and incorporate his responses. Clausewitz acknowledges that friction creates enormous difficulties for the realization of any plan, but it is precisely in respect of this challenge that he develops the concept of military genius, whose capabilities are seen above all as the executive arm of planning. KEY WORDS: Clausewitz, planning, chaos Did Clausewitz regard war planning as a contradiction in terms? His description of war as ‘a continuous interaction of opposites ’ (p.136)1 in which ‘my opponent... dictates to me as much as I dictate to him’ (p.77) seems to imply that neither side could hope to conduct its operations in accordance with a preconceived plan. Nor are the enemy’s countermeasures seen as the only hindrance to the realization of a plan: there is also the problem of ‘friction’, the innumerable slight malfunctions and mishaps which ‘combine to lower the general level of performance, so that one always falls far short of the intended goal’ (p.119). How long could any plan survive in such a doubly resistant medium? According to Beatrice Heuser, Clausewitz ‘wrote that no war plan outlasts the first encounter with the enemy, a view that was echoed by Moltke’.2 That is indeed a well-known opinion of Field Marshal 1All page numbers given in my text refer to Carl von Clausewitz, On War, ed. and

References

3