The influence of language-switching experience on the bilingual executive control advantage

Nele Verreyt, Evy Woumans, Davy Vandelanotte, Arnaud Szmalec, Wouter Duyck

Bilingualism Language and Cognition · 2015 · 272 citations · 43 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Bilingualism’s effect on non‑linguistic executive control remains contested in current research. This study examined whether language‑switching experience, rather than second‑language proficiency, drives the bilingual executive control advantage. Researchers compared unbalanced bilinguals, balanced non‑switching bilinguals, and balanced switching bilinguals on flanker and Simon tasks to assess executive control performance. Balanced switching bilinguals outperformed the other groups, indicating that language‑switching experience—not high proficiency—is the key factor for the bilingual advantage in interference resolution.

Abstract

In an ongoing debate, bilingual research currently discusses whether bilingualism enhances non-linguistic executive control. The goal of this study was to investigate the influence of language-switching experience, rather than language proficiency, on this bilingual executive control advantage. We compared the performance of unbalanced bilinguals, balanced non-switching, and balanced switching bilinguals on two executive control tasks, i.e. a flanker and a Simon task. We found that the balanced switching bilinguals outperformed both other groups in terms of executive control performance, whereas the unbalanced and balanced non-switching bilinguals did not differ. These findings indicate that language-switching experience, rather than high second-language proficiency, is the key determinant of the bilingual advantage in cognitive control processes related to interference resolution.

References

43