The story they want to tell, and the visual story as evidence: young people, research authority and research purposes in the education and health domains

Lyn Yates

Visual Studies · 2010 · 89 citations · 25 references

Concepts

Abstract

Abstract The decision to use participatory visual methods with young people in education, health or public policy research is linked to a desire to allow them to have some greater voice in the research and the professional activities that impact on their lives. But how that ‘voice’ is produced, whose voice it represents, and how the product of that research is used and interpreted are all contentious issues for researchers. This article analyses some of these conceptual, methodological, political and pragmatic issues from the perspective of a current Australian Research Council-funded project working with young people across education and health domains. It is argued that allowing or not allowing visual accounts to speak for themselves is not simply a political decision but one related to epistemological understandings about meaning, and also to different purposes of different visual projects, in particular their relative emphasis on voice as a window to the world of the young people, compared with voice as a window to ‘who I am’. The project discussed is one which aims to give greater authority and centrality to the visual accounts and voices of young people, but also one where researchers understand both the visual and voice as constructed rather than given. Case studies from the project are used to illustrate the way in which these commitments frame decisions about technology and methodology, and also to show and argue for an approach which treats the meaning of the visual evidence as something to be constructed ethnographically and reflexively over time. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The author acknowledges funding support for the project A Multi-disciplinary Investigation of How Trauma and Chronic Illness Impact on Schooling, Identity and Social Connectivity from the Australian Research Council and the RCH Education Institute and her appreciation for the participation and contribution made by ‘Alice’ and ‘Jasmine’ and their families. The article draws on and has benefited from many conversations with other members of the project team: Julianne Moss, Sarah Drew, Julie White, Trevor Hay, Peter Ferguson, Pam St Leger, Mary Dixon, Lyndal Bond, Margaret Robertson, Tony Potas, Julie Green and Hannah Walker. Notes [1] The project is co-funded by the Australian Research Council and the Melbourne Royal Children's Hospital Education Institute as an ARC Linkage Project (LP0669735). The research team comprises: chief investigators Lyn Yates, Julianne Moss, Trevor Hay, Pam St Leger, Peter Ferguson (all from Melbourne Graduate School of Education (MGSE), University of Melbourne); Sarah Drew (Centre for Adolescent Health (CAH), University of Melbourne/Royal Children's Hospital); Julie White (La Trobe University), Mary Dixon (Deakin University); Lyndal Bond (Social and Health Sciences Unit, Glasgow); partner research associates Julie Green, Tony Potas and Margaret Robertson (Royal Children's Hospital Education Institute); project research associates Hannah Walker, Ria Hanewald and Katie Wright (MGSE); and Amy Basile (CAH). The project website is: http://www.edfac.unimelb.edu.au/keepingconnected [2] Other parts of the project include background review of databases relating to the education institute and its clients; a survey of the overall cohort; retrospective interviews with previous clients of the education institute, now in their twenties; interviews with parents and education and health professionals; and an ongoing reflexive attention to the disciplinary differences members of the research team bring to their interpretations. [3] Personal communication from Dr Sarah Drew, who has also worked on a number of projects with the Centre for Adolescent Health as well as on her doctoral project on young people with cancer (Drew Citation2003). See also Guillemin and Drew Citation2010. [4] The only instructions about content in the ‘tip sheet’ said this: ‘We would like the photos to relate to you and important everyday experiences, including school and living with an ongoing health condition in some way. […] The points listed below are some general things you might like to take photos of. You don't need to include these photos if you don't want to. (Meaningful people or places/Being at school or home/Visits to doctors or the hospital or other health care appointments/Activities or items from daily life/Spending time with classmates or friends/Out of school activities & hobbies/Anything else you think is important.) If you feel like being creative – don't be afraid to try different things. If something doesn't work out, don't worry, that's photography and movie making!’ [5] Because we do not have permission to publish from others depicted in photographs, I have restricted these photographs from a school camp to one where Alice is the subject.

References

25