Disease as Justice: Perceptions of the Victims of Physical Illness

Jessie Gruman, Richard P. Sloan

Basic and Applied Social Psychology · 1983 · 39 citations · 11 references

Concepts

Abstract

According to Lerner's "Just World Hypothesis," innocent victims of misfortune threaten our belief that people get what they deserve and deserve what they get. In such cases of misfortune, we typically derogate the victim in an attempt to convince ourselves that he is the kind of person who deserves to suffer. This study examined this hypothesis in regard to a specific misfortune: physical illness. College students were presented with stimulus stories describing a person, either similar or dissimilar to them, who was either in good health or suffering from one of three diseases: indigestion, pneumonia, or stomach cancer. Moreover, subjects were presented with instructions designed to promote or inhibit empathy. After reading the stories, they rated the stimulus person's attractiveness as a measure of derogation. It was predicted that 1) victims of illness would be derogated relative to healthy persons and 2) derogation would increase as the severity of the illness increased. As predicted, ill persons were derogated relative to healthy ones. With the exception of cancer victims, derogation increased with increasing severity of illness.

References

11