Essentialism: origin and order

Tim Robertson

Mind · 2000 · 13 citations · 2 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Rawlins propped the heel of one boot atop the toe of the other.As if to pace off the heavens.My daddy run off from home when he was fifteen.Otherwise I'd of been born in Alabama.You wouldn't of been born at all.What makes you say that?Cause your mama's from San Angelo and he never would of met her.He'd of met somebody.So would she.So?So you wouldn't of been born.I don't see why you say that.I'd of been born somewheres.How? Well why not? You're makin my goddamn head hurt.I know it.I'm makin my own.Cormac McCarthy, All the Pretty Horses1 Since the main concern of Hawthorne and Gendler is Salmon's argument and not Forbes's, I discuss only the former.2 "Tak[ing] the liberty of ignoring the complications raised by [their revision of the sufficiency premise]" Hawthorne and Gendler (2000, 7-8) actually discuss my first counterexample with respect to Salmon's version rather than their own.I will make clear that the first counterexample does apply to their revision.

References

2