Network Ecology and Adolescent Social Structure

Daniel A. McFarland, James Moody, David Diehl, Jeffrey A. Smith, Reuben J. Thomas

American Sociological Review · 2014 · 332 citations · 83 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Adolescent social networks range from caste‑like hierarchies to flat cliques, and explaining this diversity is difficult because global structure is typically seen as the aggregate of micro‑level tie‑formation mechanisms such as balance, homophily, and dominance. The study seeks to determine how identical micro‑mechanisms can generate diverse global network structures. Using longitudinal friendship data from Add Health and Classroom Engagement, the authors extend exponential random graph models to test a network ecological theory that shows how environmental features moderate tie‑formation processes to produce structural variation across settings.

Abstract

Adolescent societies—whether arising from weak, short-term classroom friendships or from close, long-term friendships—exhibit various levels of network clustering, segregation, and hierarchy. Some are rank-ordered caste systems and others are flat, cliquish worlds. Explaining the source of such structural variation remains a challenge, however, because global network features are generally treated as the agglomeration of micro-level tie-formation mechanisms, namely balance, homophily, and dominance. How do the same micro-mechanisms generate significant variation in global network structures? To answer this question we propose and test a network ecological theory that specifies the ways features of organizational environments moderate the expression of tie-formation processes, thereby generating variability in global network structures across settings. We develop this argument using longitudinal friendship data on schools (Add Health study) and classrooms (Classroom Engagement study), and by extending exponential random graph models to the study of multiple societies over time.

References

83