Systematic Reviews of Animal Studies; Missing Link in Translational Research?

Judith van Luijk, Brenda Bakker, Maroeska M. Rovers, Merel Ritskes‐Hoitinga, Rob B.M. de Vries, Marlies Leenaars

PLoS ONE · 2014 · 91 citations · 10 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The methodological quality of animal studies is a key barrier to translating preclinical findings into clinical practice. The study aimed to evaluate risk‑of‑bias assessment in animal‑based systematic reviews and to examine the internal validity of the primary animal studies they include. The authors systematically searched PubMed and Embase for systematic reviews of preclinical animal studies published 2005–2012, identifying 91 reviews that met inclusion criteria. Among the 91 systematic reviews, risk‑of‑bias assessment was performed in 52.7 % and only 36.3 % provided sufficient data to evaluate internal validity, revealing that among primary studies only 24.6 % were randomized, 14.6 % reported investigator blinding, 23.9 % blinded outcome assessment, and 23.1 % reported drop‑outs, underscoring the need for improved internal validity and routine risk‑of‑bias evaluation in animal studies.

Abstract

The methodological quality of animal studies is an important factor hampering the translation of results from animal studies to a clinical setting. Systematic reviews of animal studies may provide a suitable method to assess and thereby improve their methodological quality.The aims of this study were: 1) to evaluate the risk of bias assessment in animal-based systematic reviews, and 2) to study the internal validity of the primary animal studies included in these systematic reviews.We systematically searched Pubmed and Embase for SRs of preclinical animal studies published between 2005 and 2012.A total of 91 systematic reviews met our inclusion criteria. The risk of bias was assessed in 48 (52.7%) of these 91 systematic reviews. Thirty-three (36.3%) SRs provided sufficient information to evaluate the internal validity of the included studies. Of the evaluated primary studies, 24.6% was randomized, 14.6% reported blinding of the investigator/caretaker, 23.9% blinded the outcome assessment, and 23.1% reported drop-outs.To improve the translation of animal data to clinical practice, systematic reviews of animal studies are worthwhile, but the internal validity of primary animal studies needs to be improved. Furthermore, risk of bias should be assessed by systematic reviews of animal studies to provide insight into the reliability of the available evidence.

References

10