International Journal of Law in Context · 2011 · 19 citations · 10 references
LawHuman Rights LawInternational LawHealth Care LawHuman RightsRight To HealthHealth RightsImmigrant HealthInternational Migration LawMigrant HealthRights Of Irregular MigrantsComparative Case Study DesignHealth Care EntitlementsHuman Rights Of MigrantsImmigrant Health Care AccessImmigration PowerMigrant Access To HealthcareMigrant Health AccessMigrants' Right To Health Care
Abstract International human rights law attaches the right of health care to the person. States, however, predicate this right on membership in the national community and access to publicly subsidised health care is normally contingent on national membership. With this in mind, this article considers the significance of a human rights approach to access to health care and undertakes a comparative study of health-care provision for irregular migrants in France and the UK. Irregular migrants are ineligible for national membership because they have breached immigration laws. Consequently their right to health care may only arise from international human rights law. This comparative study, however, shows that states resist the idea of a right to health care for people they regard as a threat to national sovereignty. Yet the author posits that the exercise of the government's immigration power may be reconciled with the realisation of irregular migrants' human right to health care.
10
Citizenship and nationhood in France and Germany
Choice Reviews Online · 1993 · 2.6K citations
Social Sciences, French, History +17
The Ethical Significance of Nationality
David Miller · Ethics · 1988 · 407 citations