An Examination of Short-Selling Activity Surrounding Auditor Changes

Abstract

Using a combination of short-selling data made available by Regulation SHO and auditor change data disclosed in companies’ SEC filings, we examine whether short sellers (a) discern between “good news” and “bad news” auditor changes and (b) increase their revenue by trading around auditor change announcements. We find that short sellers systematically increase activity following certain auditor changes, which include auditor downgrades (i.e., change from Big 4 auditor to non-Big 4 auditor), auditor resignations, and auditor changes involving a disagreement between management and the departing auditor. Our results indicate that short sellers are able to generate significant returns by systematically taking short positions pursuant to specific types of “bad news” changes.