The Mechanism of the Slippage Approach to Rotaxanes. Origin of the “All-or-Nothing” Substituent Effect

Françisco M. Raymo, K. N. Houk, J. Fraser Stoddart

Journal of the American Chemical Society · 1998 · 146 citations · 16 references

Concepts

Abstract

Heating a solution of the circular bis- p -phenylene-34-crown-10 and a dumbbell-shaped bipyridinium component, terminated at both ends by 4- R -phenyl-bis(4- tert -butyl-phenyl)methane-based stoppers, affords the corresponding [2]rotaxane when R is equal to H, Me, and Et, following the slippage of the macrocycle over the stoppers of the dumbbell. By contrast, no [2]rotaxane is obtained when R is equal to i -Pr. Computational investigations with the AMBER* force field provide an explanation of this dramatic substitutent effect. The phenomenon was simulated by the passage of the bis- p -phenylene-34-crown-10 macrocycle over four 4- R -phenyl-bis(4- tert -butyl-phenyl)methane model stoppers. For R equal to H, Me, Et, and i -Pr, there are two main energy barriers which have to be surpassed in order to permit the passage of the macrocycle over the bulky stoppers. When R is equal to H or Me, the rate-determining step is the passage of the macrocycle over a t -Bu-C 6 H 4 - ring. By contrast, when R is equal to Et or i -Pr, the rate-determining step becomes the passage of the macrocycle over the R -C 6 H 4 - ring. However, when R is equal to i -Pr, the resulting energy barrier is more than 21 kcal mol - 1 higher than in the case of any of the other stoppers. These results are in good agreement with the experimental observations and provide a quantitative explanation for the rigorous size complementarity requirements between macrocycle and stopper which have been observed experimentally.

References

16