Text and Talk · 2008 · 26 citations · 10 references
LawCriminal LawLinguisticsDiscourse AnalysisForensic LinguisticsRhetoricArgumentationCase AnalysisChild Sexual AbuseLegal ArgumentationLegal Discourse AnalysisLegal RhetoricClosing Argument DiscourseClosing Argument RhetoricLegal Case Discourse AnalysisLegal Genre AnalysisRhetoric In Legal ArgumentSocial Representation TheoryTrial RhetoricVictim Representation In Court
In this article, I first propose a methodology for the analysis of closing arguments in criminal trials, an understudied linguistic genre, that can be used to expose how lawyers take the same defendant, victim, and evidence and linguistically create opposing discursive representations of the case. Using the theoretical insights of Van Leeuwen (2002), Halliday (1994), and Huckin (2002), I critically examine how the main social actors are referred to, how the processes or actions those actors took part in are referenced, and what topics are included and silenced by each side to see how lawyers are systematically creating different representations of reality. Using the analysis of the arguments presented in a sexual abuse case, I show that the lawyers in this particular case are constructing different models of the case not by contradicting each other but through their control of what is included in their argument and how the social actors and their actions are depicted.
10
Teun A. van Dijk · Discourse & Society · 2006 · 1.3K citations
Textual silence and the discourse of homelessness
Thomas N. Huckin · Discourse & Society · 2002 · 251 citations
Cotext as context: vague answers in court
Richard W. Janney · Language & Communication · 2002 · 126 citations
’Baby’ or ’fetus’?: Language and the construction of reality in a manslaughter trial
Brenda Danet · Semiotica · 1980 · 119 citations
Law, Criminal Law, Human Rights Law +11