Geographical Research · 2007 · 175 citations · 36 references
Social SciencesGeographyHuman GeographyEpistemologyIndigenous StudiesKnowledge CreationIndigenous GeographiesIndigenous KnowledgeIndigenous Knowledge SystemsInterpretive AnthropologyKnowledge ProductionTraditional KnowledgeAdaptive SystemsIndigenous MappingIndigenous Narrative TraditionsIndigenous Spatial KnowledgeMapping Indigenous KnowledgeOntologies
Maps can be viewed as representations of reality or as spatially referenced data assemblages, yet Indigenous knowledge traditions and multiple ontologies create a dilemma. The study aims to enable different knowledge traditions and mapping approaches to collaborate without being subsumed into a single universal ontology. It reconceives mapping and knowing performatively and hodologically, employing cognitive trails to capture encounters, tensions, and cooperation among traditions, thereby creating a dialogical, socially distributed knowledge base that supports emergent mapping. The authors argue that a distributed knowledge database emulating a complex adaptive system allows differing traditions to interact and interrogate each other, with cognitive trails fostering dialogical tension that enables emergent mapping.
Abstract If maps are conceived as representations of reality or as spatially referenced data assemblages, a dilemma is raised by the nature of Indigenous knowledge traditions and multiple ontologies. How can differing knowledge traditions, differing ways of mapping be enabled to work together without subsumption into one common or universal ontology? The paper explores one way of handling this dilemma by reconceiving mapping and knowing performatively and hodologically. It is argued that one way in which differing knowledge traditions can interact and be mutually interrogated is by creating a database structured as distributed knowledge and emulating a complex adaptive system. Through focusing on the encounters, tensions and cooperations between traditions and utilising the concept of cognitive trails‐ the creation of knowledge by movement through the natural and intellectual environment – the socially distributed performative dimensions of differing modes of spatially organised knowledges can then be held in a dialogical tension that enables emergent mapping.
36
Not by Genes Alone: How Culture Transformed Human Evolution
Martin H. Levinson · et Cetera · 2006 · 3.6K citations
Rethinking Community‐Based Conservation
Fikret Berkes · Conservation Biology · 2004 · 1.9K citations · Full text