Fifteen Years of<i>Quality in Higher Education</i>(Part Two)

Lee Harvey, James Williams

Quality in Higher Education · 2010 · 154 citations · 133 references

Concepts

TL;DR

This review examines papers published in *Quality in Higher Education* from 1995 to the present, noting that quality assurance has become an international concern with increasingly standardised procedures across national boundaries. The study focuses on internal quality assurance, learning and teaching improvements, and the impact assessment of quality assurance. The review analyzes papers on quality enhancement instruments, particularly student feedback surveys that have gained prominence since the early 1990s. The review finds that while quality assurance has improved documentation and transparency, external processes remain poorly aligned with daily academic activity, the consumerist approach has limited enthusiasm, academia shows inertia, and it remains unclear whether QA systems have truly enhanced higher education after 15 years.

Abstract

ABSTRACT This is the second part of the review of the papers published in Quality in Higher Education from its inception in 1995 to the present day. This part of the review focuses on internal quality assurance, improvements in learning and teaching and assessments of the impact of quality assurance. In doing so, the review also examines papers about quality enhancement instruments such as student feedback surveys, which have played an increasingly prominent role in quality processes since the early 1990s. The review suggests that quality assurance has resulted in clearer documentation and transparency although external processes could be better aligned to everyday academic activity. Quality assurance has become an international concern and procedures have become increasingly standardised across national boundaries. Significantly, the consumerist approach to higher education quality that is driven by governments and senior management, has not met with enthusiasm from contributors to the journal and there appears to be a strong commitment to autonomy and academic freedom. However, papers indicate that academia is prone to inertia and compliant indifference. Ultimately, the review suggests that it is still not clear that, even after 15 years, quality assurance systems have really enhanced higher education.

References

133