Restructuring Industrial Districts, Scaling Up Regional Development: A Study of the Wenzhou Model, China

Yehua Dennis Wei, Wangming Li, Chunbin Wang

Economic Geography · 2007 · 218 citations · 51 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Wenzhou, a leading Chinese municipality, has driven marketization through family‑owned small businesses that resemble Marshallian industrial districts, but changing institutions, rising competition, and recent growth slowdown raise concerns about the model’s sustainability. The study contends that Wenzhou’s growth risks regional lock‑ins of relational, intergenerational, and structural nature. The authors trace two major restructuring waves since the late 1980s, encompassing institutional change, technological upgrading, industrial diversification, spatial restructuring, and the rise of new firms, clusters, mergers, acquisitions, and multiregional enterprises relocating headquarters to Shanghai and Hangzhou. The findings show that Wenzhou’s experience challenges orthodox industrial‑district theory and advocates scaling up regional development.

Abstract

Abstract: The Wenzhou Municipality in Zhejiang Province is spearheading China' marketization and development of private enterprises. Its successful development trajectory, centered on family‐owned small businesses embedded in thick local institutions, resembles Marshallian industrial districts (MIDs). However, with China' changing institutional environment and intensifying competition, Wenzhou has been facing challenges. Since the late 1980s, Wenzhou has gone through two major rounds of restructuring (from family enterprises to shareholding cooperatives to shareholding enterprises), that have included four major types of strategic response: institutional change, technological upgrading, industrial diversification, and spatial restructuring. Firms in Wenzhou have gone through localization and delocalization, and locational choices reflect the dual destinations of globalizing cities and interior cities. The formation of new firms and clusters has been accompanied by mergers, acquisitions, and the emergence of multiregional enterprises (MREs), some of which have relocated their headquarters and specialized functions to metropolitan areas, especially Shanghai and Hangzhou. More recently, Wenzhou' growth has slowed, leading some to question the sustainability of the Wenzhou model. We argue that Wenzhou' development is in danger of regional lock‐ins—relational, intergenerational, and structural. Wenzhou' experience challenges the orthodox concept of MIDs and calls for “scaling up” regional development.

References

51