Social SciencesPsychologyCognitive DevelopmentExperimental PsychologyInteraction DesignDirect Manipulation InterfacesObject ManipulationSpatial CognitionTangible User InterfacesDirect ManipulationJigsaw Puzzle SolvingMouse InputTangible InteractionTangible Learning InterfacesTemporal Analysis
We investigate the similarities and differences -- in terms of quantitative performance and qualitative behaviors -- between how children solve an object manipulation task using mouse-based input versus tangible-based input. This work examines the assumption common in tangible computing that direct physical manipulation is beneficial for certain spatial tasks. We describe an ecologically valid comparison of mouse-based versus tangible-based input for a jigsaw puzzle task in order to better understand the tradeoffs in choosing input and interaction styles. We include a traditional cardboard puzzle for comparative purposes. The results of an experiment with 132 children indicate children are more successful and faster at solving puzzles using a tangible-based approach. Detailed temporal analysis indicates that pairs in the tangible group spend most of their time using a combination of epistemic and pragmatic actions which support mental problem solving. Conversely, pairs in the mouse group use an ineffective trial and error strategy.
23
Hiroshi Ishii, Brygg Ullmer · 1997 · 3.8K citations
Arts, Computer Science, Media Arts +17
Being There: Putting Brain, Body and World Together Again.
Tim van Gelder, Andy Clark · The Philosophical Review · 1998 · 3.2K citations
Humanities, Neuroscience, Psychology +12
Hearing gesture: how our hands help us think
Choice Reviews Online · 2004 · 1.2K citations
George Fitzmaurice, Hiroshi Ishii, William Buxton · 1995 · 969 citations
Jun Rekimoto · 2002 · 633 citations
Engineering, Mechatronics Engineering, Assistive Technology +16