Children (but not women) first: New Labour, child welfare and gender

Ruth Lister

Critical Social Policy · 2006 · 234 citations · 30 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

New Labour’s social investment agenda places children at the centre of welfare policy, yet critics argue it treats children as future workers, marginalises certain groups, and sidelines mothers’ welfare. The study proposes modifications to the social investment model to better promote children’s well‑being and gender‑equitable outcomes. The authors outline a framework for adjusting the social investment strategy, drawing on principles of gendered social justice. The paper reviews child‑focused policies that both invest in children and regulate them alongside their parents and mothers.

Abstract

The paper’s starting point is an analysis of New Labour’s agenda for children in an emergent ‘social investment state’. It provides an overview of policies for children, which simultaneously invest in children and regulate them and their parents/mothers. Although children have moved to the heart of social policy, there is some disquiet about the way they are being positioned in this brave new world of social investment. This disquiet focuses in particular on: the construction of children as ‘becomings’ rather than ‘beings’; the paid-work-focused and future-oriented model of citizenship; the relative neglect of groups of children who are not seen to represent such a good investment; and the eclipse of parents’, and in particular, mothers’ welfare. The final section sketches out how the social investment approach might be modified in the interests of children’s well-being and flourishing and with reference to principles of (gendered) social justice.

References

30