Daedalus · 1971 · 14 citations · 0 references
HumanitiesEthnic StudiesHigher EducationAfrican American EducationAfrican American PoliticsHigher Education LeadershipBlack CommunitiesBlack StudiesRace In SchoolingRacismWhiteness In EducationBlack Community PowerBlack Higher EducationNormative InstitutionsRace In Higher EducationRacialized Experiences In Education
Black colleges have been roundly excoriated by diverse ele ments1 for defaulting on their responsibilities to the larger black community. There are those who argue that black colleges have been too elitist and have not given proper deference to the opinions and judgments of the masses, while others have criticized them for failing to take the initiative in giving these same masses suffici ent guidance and leadership. Some have inveighed against them for failing to approximate the role attributed to major white col eges in American society as a whole, while others have vehemently denounced them for slavishly aping such institutions. These crit icisms, along with myriad others repeatedly leveled at black col leges, obviously have some bases in fact. Black colleges have not completely fulfilled their responsibilities to the larger black com munity. However, much of the criticism suggests a profound mis understanding of the relationship between institutions of higher learning and their sponsoring communities in general and an even more skewed perception of the place of black colleges in American society. Indeed, the critics themselves are often inconsistent, criti cizing black colleges for not being good American colleges on the one hand and for not meeting their special responsibilities to the black community on the other.2 Such specious analysis is a function of the fact that much of the discussion of the role and responsibilities of black colleges rushes pell-mell toward evaluation before giving sufficient attention to the societal context within which they are obliged to function. Funda mental questions and their implications for the role performance of black colleges go begging?questions such as: Who decided that black colleges should be established and what purposes did they have in mind? How did these purposes affect the recruitment of 732