Comparing two types of augmentative and alternative communication systems for children with autism

Seung Hyun Son, Jeff Sigafoos, Mark F. O’Reilly, Giulio E. Lancioni

Pediatric Rehabilitation · 2006 · 97 citations · 14 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study compared acquisition and preference for picture‑exchange and voice‑output communication aide systems in three preschoolers with autism. Using an alternating‑treatments design, the researchers measured acquisition of requesting behavior with each system and then allowed simultaneous availability for child‑chosen use. Acquisition rates were similar for both systems, but two children preferred picture‑exchange and one preferred VOCA, indicating that both speed and preference should guide AAC intervention design.

Abstract

This study compared acquisition and preference for two types of augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) systems in three pre-schoolers with autism. Acquisition of requesting behaviour using a picture-exchange system vs a voice-output communication aide (VOCA) was compared in an alternating treatments design. Following acquisition, both ACC systems were simultaneously available and the child could select which one of the two systems to use. There was little difference between picture-exchange and VOCA in terms of acquisition rates. Two children demonstrated a consistent preference for picture-exchange and the third showed a preference for the VOCA. Both speed of acquisition and system preference should be considered when designing AAC interventions for children with autism and related developmental disabilities.

References

14