FRAX calculator and Garvan nomogram in male osteoporotic population

Wojciech Pluskiewicz, Piotr Adamczyk, Edward Franek, Ewa Sewerynek, Piotr Leszczyński, Hanna Wichrowska, Luiza Napiórkowska, Michał Stuss, Aleksandra L. Ptaszek, Tomasz Kostyk,

The Aging Male · 2014 · 19 citations · 15 references

Concepts

Abstract

PURPOSE: The aim of the study was the presentation of osteoporotic fracture prediction in men. METHODS: Eight-hundred and one men at the mean age of 70.8 ± 9.31 years were examined. The 10-year fracture prediction was established, using the FRAX calculator and Garvan nomogram. RESULTS: The mean value for any fracture and hip fracture probabilities for FRAX were 7.26 ± 5.4% and 3.68 ± 4.25%, respectively. For Garvan fracture, risk values were 26.44 ± 23.83% and 12.02 ± 18.1%. The mean conformity for any fracture and hip fracture prediction for threshold of 20% (any fracture) and 3% (hip fracture) between Garvan and FRAX values was 55.8% (κ 0.041) and 79.65% (κ 0.599), respectively. ROC analyses showed the following areas under the ROC curves (AUC) for any fractures: FRAX 0.808 and Garvan nomogram 0.843 (p = 0.059). The AUC values for hip fractures were 0.748 for Garvan nomogram and for 0.749 FRAX, and did not differ. On the base of ROC data, the cut-off values with best accuracy to predict fractures for both methods were established. The conformity between methods for thresholds indicated by ROC analysis was 72.5% (κ 0.435) for any and 77.7% (κ 0.543) for hip fractures. CONCLUSION: The conformities between FRAX and Garvan in regard to hip fracture prediction were acceptable for a threshold of 3% and thresholds derived by ROC analysis, while for any fracture we recommend to use thresholds established by ROC analysis. This may suggest that the use of "universal" cut-off points is probably misleading.

References

15