Arbitration is No Substitute for State Courts

Stefan Voigt, Sang-min Park

The Journal of Development Studies · 2013 · 18 citations · 13 references

Concepts

Abstract

It is often conjectured that non-state dispute resolution blossoms when state courts are not independent or are perceived as low quality. This conjecture implies a substitutive relationship between state and non-state dispute resolution. This is the first study that puts these hypotheses to an empirical test. We estimate a multilevel model based on more than 10, 000 surveyed firms in some 50 countries. We find that perceived quality of state courts and the frequency with which firms resort to non-state dispute resolution are positively correlated and that, hence, state courts and non-state dispute resolution are complements, rather than substitutes. The hope of some policy-makers that development can be spurred by improving the conditions for non-state dispute resolution thus appears to be in vain.

References

13