Systematic Classification of Disease Severity for Evaluation of Expanded Carrier Screening Panels

Gabriel A. Lazarin, Felicia Hawthorne, Nicholas S. Collins, Elizabeth A. Platt, Eric A. Evans, Imran S. Haque

PLoS ONE · 2014 · 148 citations · 11 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Professional guidelines require disease severity as a key criterion for carrier screening, and expanded carrier panels need an objective, systematic severity description. The study hypothesized that diseases with high‑impact characteristics would be rated most severe, while lower‑impact diseases would be rated less severe. A pilot survey of 192 health‑care professionals assessed how phenotypic characteristics influence perceived severity and used these responses to develop an algorithm that classifies diseases into Profound, Severe, Moderate, or Mild based on characteristic combinations. The results confirmed the hypothesis, identifying four severity tiers and demonstrating that the algorithm provides a simple, replicable, and low‑labor classification of disease severity.

Abstract

Professional guidelines dictate that disease severity is a key criterion for carrier screening. Expanded carrier screening, which tests for hundreds to thousands of mutations simultaneously, requires an objective, systematic means of describing a given disease's severity to build screening panels. We hypothesized that diseases with characteristics deemed to be of highest impact would likewise be rated as most severe, and diseases with characteristics of lower impact would be rated as less severe. We describe a pilot test of this hypothesis in which we surveyed 192 health care professionals to determine the impact of specific disease phenotypic characteristics on perceived severity, and asked the same group to rate the severity of selected inherited diseases. The results support the hypothesis: we identified four "Tiers" of disease characteristics (1–4). Based on these responses, we developed an algorithm that, based on the combination of characteristics normally seen in an affected individual, classifies the disease as Profound, Severe, Moderate, or Mild. This algorithm allows simple classification of disease severity that is replicable and not labor intensive.

References

11