Varieties of Healing. 2: A Taxonomy of Unconventional Healing Practices

Ted J. Kaptchuk, David M. Eisenberg

Annals of Internal Medicine · 2001 · 157 citations · 77 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The United States has a long history of medical pluralism, yet alternative medicine remains a residual, heterogeneous category lacking a clear definition. This essay aims to provide an overview and descriptive taxonomy of contemporary unconventional medical practices in the United States. The taxonomy distinguishes a mainstream complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) category—further divided into professional groups, lay movements, New Age, alternative psychological therapies, and non‑normative science—from a culture‑bound parochial category comprising ethno‑medicine, religious healing, and folk medicine. A topological analysis of U.S.

Abstract

The first of two essays in this issue demonstrated that the United States has had a rich history of medical pluralism. This essay seeks to present an overview of contemporary unconventional medical practices in the United States. No clear definition of "alternative medicine" is offered because it is a residual category composed of heterogeneous healing methods. A descriptive taxonomy of contemporary unconventional healing could be more helpful. Two broad categories of unconventional medicine are described here: a more prominent, "mainstream" complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) and a more culture-bound, "parochial" unconventional medicine. The CAM component can be divided into professional groups, layperson-initiated popular health reform movements, New Age healing, alternative psychological therapies, and non-normative scientific enterprises. The parochial category can be divided into ethno-medicine, religious healing, and folk medicine. A topologic examination of U.S. health care can provide an important conceptual framework through which health care providers can understand the current situation in U.S. medical pluralism.

References

77