Health Information & Libraries Journal · 2009 · 13 citations · 2 references
Public HealthHealth EducationHealth CommunicationHealth Information SystemsHealth LiteracyHealth Education CurriculumHealth Literacy SupportInformation LiteracyInformed Decision-makingHealth Information AccessHealth Information NeedHealth Literacy EducationHealth Literacy TrainingPatient Health Literacy
In her last learning and teaching in action column (December 2008) Margaret Forrest talked about adding value to the library and information profession. In our profession this is something that is demanded of us and is something that we all strive to, and many of us do regularly, achieve. In my first column Eilean Craig discusses the way in which NHS Education for Scotland are looking to reinforce the importance, and show the value, of their teaching by creating and implementing an information literacy framework. Eilean Craig, Knowledge Outreach Manager, NHS Education for Scotland, Clifton House, 1 Clifton Place, Glasgow, G3 7LD. E-mail: [email protected] Better Informed for Better Health and Better Care: An Information Literacy Framework to Support Health Care in Scotland 1 is the current draft proposal from the NHS Education for Scotland. The Scottish Government action plan Better Health, Better Care2 acknowledges the need for the confident and competent use of information, in order to meet the Government's aspiration for a healthier Scotland. Better Health, Better Care states: ‘Health and social care professionals need quick access to information and to have the skills to use the knowledge appropriately’. However, the aims of the plan are not limited to the employees of NHSScotland. There is also a commitment in the document to create a National Health Information and Support Service which will ensure that patients and public ‘get support to find the information they need; understand the information provided and develop the skills and confidence to use it effectively in order to become an active partner in their own care’. The idea of a National Health Knowledge Network, supporting the development of information literacy among staff, patients and carers, is one of the stated aims of the coordinated national strategy for NHSScotland Knowledge Services (Enabling Partnerships: Sharing knowledge for Scotland's health and healthcare3). The document states that information and knowledge are powerful tools that can be used to strengthen patient care and improve people's health. The strategy goes on to describe various ways to help ensure that in future patients, the public, health care staff and partner agencies have access to the information they need, when they need it. Information literacy is also acknowledged as being key to empowering individuals and communities to take more control over their health and well-being and life circumstances. The purpose of the Framework is to encourage and support the development and enhancement of the information finding and evaluation skills, values and attitudes of the people involved in improving health and caring for patients.1 It is intended for NHS Scotland staff, partner organizations, patients, carers and members of the public who wish to further their information literacy capabilities and, consequently, contribute to health improvement and better service delivery. During training and demonstration sessions conducted by Knowledge Services Group, it became apparent that the term ‘information literacy’ was not readily recognized within NHSScotland and that the meaning of the phrase was often confused with ‘literacy’ as it applies to basic abilities in reading and writing. Additionally, there was some resistance to the expression, with many preferring the term ‘knowledge management’. This latter finding reflects the conclusions of several Australian studies such as that of Kirkton and Barham.4 However, ‘knowledge management’ is not synonymous with ‘information literacy’ and, as Cheuk5 reports, investment in technology, the appointment of knowledge management staff and an abundant supply of content and resource support achieve very little in any organization where the majority of the staff is information illiterate. This same idea is expressed more simply by Goad: without information one cannot have knowledge and, similarly, without information literacy one cannot have knowledge management.6 As a first step in supporting information literacy development and enhancement throughout NHSScotland, we have produced a series of online training courses. One of these targets health care practitioners and another is intended for administrative, clerical and support services staff. A third is planned, which will be designed for use by patients, carers and members of the public. (The current courses are available at http://www.infoskills.scot.nhs.uk.) These, and the processes used in their creation are described in a previous article.7 Registration in the courses has been better than anticipated, with over 800 people signing up to participate, and feedback has been, in the main, positive. However, some observations from participants indicate that it is difficult to connect information literacy with their own everyday activities, despite the fact that the online courses include brief scenarios demonstrating the application of the skills in context. It was decided that another method of assisting the development of information literacy throughout NHSScotland was to produce a standard or framework relating to information literacy skills and abilities, similar to other occupational competencies and standards applicable in the organization. The Framework was to be relevant to health care professionals and to administrative, clerical and support services staff within NHSScotland and partner organizations, including those in the voluntary sector, and to patients, to carers and to members of the public. Before launching the project, we released a general invitation to form a Steering Group whose tasks were to develop an understandable definition of the term ‘information literacy’ and to guide the development of the Framework. Group membership was drawn from the health and education sectors and included an independent consultant and an acknowledged expert in the field of information literacy and learning. The initial task of defining the term proved to be one of the more challenging faced by the group. We each knew exactly what we meant when we used the phrase but, defining it in a way that would be clear to those with no experience of information literacy was extremely difficult. A number of previously developed definitions were consulted8–11 as we produced, revised, reviewed, altered and amended our description. Eventually, we agreed on: An information literate person can recognize an information need and is able to apply the set of transferable skills, attitudes and behaviours needed to find, retrieve, assess, manage and apply information in any situation, throughout life. Information literacy supports individual and organizational learning, creativity and innovation and contributes to improved health care delivery through a continuously evolving, reliable information base. We also wanted to include a ‘quick reference’ for those who would be using the Framework. Therefore, using the information literacy process model which had been developed in conjunction with the online courses, we developed a reference page illustrating and explaining the process as it was to be presented in the Framework (Fig. 1). The model of the information literacy process. The model used is intended to illustrate, very simply, the seven basic stages of the information literacy process The model itself consists of seven coloured arrows and, as we create and release tools and resources, we use the arrow colours as a ‘code’ to help users identify where they are in the process. For example, the Question arrow (the usual starting point for a search) is red and each of our resources relating to formulating questions has a red marking attached to it. (See the information literacy portal for examples at http://www.infoliteracy.scot.nhs.uk.) Next, it was necessary to consider the issues raised in training and presentation sessions and the feedback supplied by those who had participated in the online tutorials. The term was not familiar or commonly used and, where it was occasionally recognized, was deemed unimportant, academic and irrelevant to real-world work situations. One of the major difficulties appeared to be a lack of awareness of the worldwide acknowledgement of information literacy as an essential characteristic of successful people, organizations and countries in this ‘Information Age’.8 This suggested that the Framework needed an introductory section which placed the concept within its historical and social context. It was important too, that the Framework and its contents reached everyone and that its practical application within the real world was apparent. As the document evolved, a section on the benefits to the organization of an information literate workforce and one on the benefits to the individual of becoming information literate were considered vital. As one of the main aims of the Framework is that it should be a practical tool having obvious application in ‘ordinary’ activities, it was essential to demonstrate the use of information literacy skills and abilities in various contexts. We incorporated a section consisting of scenarios based in clinical, educational, health inequalities and service improvement situations. Each contextual example consists of a scenario describing a situation where at least one of the actors requires information in order to solve a problem. The application of the information literacy process in meeting this need is demonstrated and explained and further illustration is provided by the inclusion of familiar, context-relevant models. As an illustration, one example is of a general practitioner (GP) who is concerned about maintaining the currency of his information on the effects of hormone replacement therapy on patients with breast cancer. The context-specific model used in this demonstration is PICO1. A JoHari window is also included to illustrate the GP's information environment. A guided reflection follows each contextual example in order to encourage readers and users of the Framework to explore the presented problem further. Each contextual scenario was verified by contacts working in the field concerned so as to ensure they are realistic. A further section of the Framework contains a series of seven capabilities tables, each of which has a heading band in the colour associated with the appropriate step of the information literacy cycle. Each of these tables provides examples of the sorts of skills, abilities and behaviours which might be learned, reinforced and observed at that stage of the process. The tables cover example learning outcomes, enabling factors, benefits to health and health care and the link between this step of the information literacy cycle and the Knowledge and Skills Framework.12 We had originally intended to produce information literacy ‘competency’ tables but, this proved to be an almost impossible task as so many competencies are underpinned by information literacy skills and abilities. The remaining parts of the Framework address: the ethical use of information, including reference to the governing legislation; a set of tables linking occupational standards and competencies to the relevant stages of the information literacy cycle; a glossary of terms used in information management; and a listing of references and further reading. The Framework was released for consultation in draft form in July of this year, with an invitation to provide comment and feedback on the content. A discussion forum was also established on the newly constructed, associated information literacy portal of the NHSScotland eLibrary (available at http://www.infoliteracy.scot.nhs.uk) as a means of providing an easier, faster way to submit comment. As a result of the breadth of the audience addressed and the need for some background on the evolution of the concept and application of ‘information literacy’, the current draft of the Framework is a document of 86 pages. This is obviously unsatisfactory and much of the feedback received to date has indicated that the size of the document makes it a daunting read. It was never our intention that every reader or user would read or would wish to read the whole of the document. We had aimed to facilitate navigation through the document by breaking it into labelled ‘chunks’. However, user comment on the draft is clearly telling us that this strategy is not effective. We are currently considering how best to address this and other issues raised by users. The document obviously needs to be presented in a different, more supportive format and one possibility is to produce a ‘boxed-set’ of related booklets, each short, concise and dedicated to a single audience group. Another possibility is to present the information in an interactive, electronic format. As consultation continues and further comment is received, we intend to develop the Framework so that it better meets the needs identified by readers and to support the spread of information literacy throughout the organization. Also planned are further tools and resources to support individual learners in developing their own information literacy and a collection of reusable materials which trainers will be able to use in their tutoring sessions.
2
Information literacy in the workplace
Jennifer Kirton, Lyn Barham · The Australian Library Journal · 2005 · 61 citations · Full text