Creativity Research Journal · 1996 · 49 citations · 19 references
EducationMusic EducationTeachingInstrumental Music EducationMusic Teacher EducationPerformance PracticeMusic LearningMusic PedagogyExpectationsMusic Performance PedagogyMusic Teacher TrainingUndergraduate Curriculum
Abstract This article reports an exploratory and descriptive study of the training of musical performers at an undergraduate level. The investigation was staged as a case study of a well-known professor of organ performance and 6 of his students. The data were gathered through participant observation, informal interviews, and questionnaires. The focus of the study is on the maestro role in an educational setting and the commonsense teaching strategy applied by such a musical maestro with no formal teacher training. The tentative findings suggest that inherent in a context of Western art music are strong expectations about how a master performance teacher should behave; this causes students to reconstrue harsh and insensitive treatment as something positive and necessary. The maestro role appears product oriented rather than person oriented, suggesting that students lacking in self-assurance and independence may fare badly under such tutelage. The article concludes by suggesting that the maestro role's potentially negative impact could be avoided if teacher training in musical performance at a higher level was given a higher priority.
19
A Theory of Social Comparison Processes
Léon Festinger · Human Relations · 1954 · 20.3K citations
Journal of personality and social psychology
Jane Armstrong · International Journal of Forecasting · 1988 · 10.6K citations
Epistemological and methodological bases of naturalistic inquiry
Egon G. Guba, Yvonna S. Lincoln · ECTJ · 1982 · 1.1K citations
Humanities, Philosophy, Epistemology +10
Teacher Praise: A Functional Analysis
Jere Brophy · Review of Educational Research · 1981 · 607 citations