Differences of Opinion, Short-Sales Constraints, and Market Crashes

Harrison Hong, Jeremy C. Stein

Review of Financial Studies · 2003 · 1.4K citations · 52 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The authors develop a theory of market crashes driven by differences of opinion among investors, explaining stylized facts and predicting that returns will be more negatively skewed when trading volume is high. Short‑sales constraints keep bearish investors out of the market initially, but when bullish investors exit, the bearish group becomes marginal support buyers, revealing hidden information. The model shows that accumulated hidden information is released during market declines, accounting for stylized crash facts and the predicted negative skewness of returns with high volume.

Abstract

We develop a theory of market crashes based on differences of opinion among investors. Because of short-sales constraints, bearish investors do not initially participate in the market and their information is not revealed in prices. However, if other previously bullish investors bail out of the market, the originally bearish group may become the marginal "support buyers," and more will be learned about their signals. Thus accumulated hidden information comes out during market declines. The model explains a variety of stylized facts about crashes and also makes a distinctive new prediction—that returns will be more negatively skewed conditional on high trading volume.

References

52