Penal policy and political economy

Michael Cavadino, James Dignan

Criminology & Criminal Justice · 2006 · 231 citations · 21 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Globalization has not led, and is unlikely to lead, to a global homogenization of penal policy and practices. The study seeks to classify the political economies of 12 contemporary capitalist countries as neo‑liberal, conservative corporatist, social democratic, or oriental corporatist. The authors analyze penal systems in these countries to identify and compare these categories. The resulting categorization correlates strongly with each country’s punitiveness and imprisonment rates, and the authors argue that this link is partly due to whether societies are inclusive or exclusive toward deviant individuals.

Abstract

Globalization has not led, and is unlikely to lead, to a global homogenization of penal policy and practices. Drawing on a study of penal systems in 12 contemporary capitalist countries (the United States of America, England and Wales, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Germany, the Netherlands, France, Italy, Sweden, Finland and Japan), this article demonstrates that the political economies of such countries can be broadly categorized as neo-liberal, conservative corporatist, social democratic or oriental corporatist. This categorization is strongly related to the punitiveness of the penal culture and the rates of imprisonment to be found in each country. The reasons for this association are discussed. One crucial factor may be the degree to which societies with different types of political economy are ‘inclusive’ rather than ‘exclusive’ towards deviant individuals.

References

21