Human Communication Research · 2013 · 234 citations · 32 references
Social SciencesPsychologySocial PsychologyExperimental PsychologyPersuasionPropagandaPropaganda TechniquesPropaganda TheoryArgument Structure AnalysisConspiracy AllegationsInoculationInoculation Biology
The study examined how inoculation and metainoculation can be used against conspiracy theory propaganda, investigating differences between fact‑based and logic‑based inoculation messages. A 3‑phase experiment with 312 participants compared a no‑treatment control, inoculation, and metainoculation groups, using a 40‑minute chapter from the 9/11 Truth film *Loose Change* as the attack message. Both inoculation and metainoculation increased resistance to the attack, with fact‑based inoculation being most effective, but metainoculation actually weakened the inoculation effect.
This investigation examined the boundaries of inoculation theory by examining how inoculation can be applied to conspiracy theory propaganda as well as inoculation itself (called metainoculation). A 3-phase experiment with 312 participants compared 3 main groups: no-treatment control, inoculation, and metainoculation. Research questions explored how inoculation and metainoculation effects differ based on the argument structure of inoculation messages (fact- vs. logic-based). The attack message was a 40-minute chapter from the 9/11 Truth conspiracy theory film, Loose Change: Final Cut. The results indicated that both the inoculation treatments induced more resistance than the control message, with the fact-based treatment being the most effective. The results also revealed that metainoculation treatments reduced the efficacy of the inoculation treatments.
32
In defense of external invalidity.
Douglas G. Mook · American Psychologist · 1983 · 1.2K citations
Brian Keeley · The Journal of Philosophy · 1999 · 578 citations
A Meta-Analysis of Research on Inoculation Theory
John A. Banas, Stephen A. Rains · Communication Monographs · 2010 · 507 citations