Distinktion Journal of Social Theory · 2015 · 63 citations · 50 references
Social SciencesSociologyIndustrial OrganizationInstitutional TheoryPolitical SociologyParty CompetitionPolitical CompetitionConstructivist InquiryHistorical SociologySociological InstitutionalismSociological Model
The article attempts to identify the particular type of competition that is at the heart of the modern faith in competition and develops a sociological research perspective on this type of competition. The first section builds on Georg Simmel's formal sociology to suggest a basic understanding of competition as a social form. The second section offers a sociological review of the modern discourse on competition since the mid-to-late eighteenth century that leads to two major insights: it shows how competition has developed into an institutionalized modern imaginary, i.e. a taken-for-granted part of our modern world-view; and it highlights that this imaginary is concerned with a particular type of competition, where suppliers are supposed to be disciplined and motivated by competition for an audience. The third section develops a sociological concept of, and an empirical research perspective on, this particular type of competition. Combining a Simmelian understanding of 'pure' competition (i.e. competition as a struggle for the favor of third parties) with recent constructivist insights on publics/audiences and comparisons as social practices, it defines modern forms of competition as competitions for the favor of an audience that are (re-)produced by public comparisons of performances. It then uses this concept to distinguish and explain a number of research questions that may guide empirical studies on prerequisites and effects of the expansion of this type of competition in different societal fields. The article concludes that, rather than believing in competition or criticizing it as a recent product of neo-liberal ideology, we should study the long-term institutionalization of modern forms of competition in various societal fields in more detail.
50
An Economic Theory of Democracy.
Edward C. Banfield, Anthony J. Downs · Midwest Journal of Political Science · 1958 · 18.9K citations
Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy
Francis Fukuyama, Joseph A. Schumpeter · Foreign Affairs · 1997 · 15.5K citations
Social Sciences, Economics, History +16
Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste.
M. Warner, Pierre Bourdıeu, Richard Nice · MLN · 1985 · 14.2K citations