Philosophical Issues · 2014 · 55 citations · 18 references
HumanitiesPhilosophyEpistemologyPhilosophy Of MindPhilosophy Of ScienceConcept FormationPhilosophy Of PerceptionReligious EpistemologyTheories Of KnowledgeAnti-luck EpistemologyEpistemology Of PerceptionPerceptionPerceptual KnowledgePerceptual Theory
Abstract The paper is an investigation into the prospects of an epistemology of non‐conceptual knowledge. According to the orthodox view, knowledge requires concepts and belief. I present several arguments to the effect that there is non‐conceptual, non‐doxastic knowledge, the obvious candidate for such knowledge being non‐conceptual perception. Non‐conceptual perception seems to be allowed for by cognitive scientists and it exhibits the central role features of knowledge—it plays the knowledge role: it respects an anti‐luck condition, it is an achievement, it enables one to act for a reason, and it provides justification. Furthermore, it makes a straightforward and elegant explanation of (doxastic) perceptual knowledge possible: doxastic perceptual knowledge builds on non‐conceptual perception as non‐conceptual knowledge. Three objections that might naturally arise will be discussed and answered. Thus, the prospects of an epistemology without belief seem to be much better than the orthodoxy wants to have it. We can extend knowledge into the non‐conceptual realm.
18
Andy Clark, David J. Chalmers · Analysis · 1998 · 5.1K citations
Timothy Williamson · 2000 · 4.9K citations
Knowledge and the Flow of Information.
William P. Alston, Fred Dretske · The Philosophical Review · 1983 · 3.3K citations
Andy Clark, David J. Chalmers · Analysis · 1998 · 668 citations
Duncan Pritchard · The Journal of Philosophy · 2012 · 571 citations · Full text