2005 · 14 citations · 0 references
EducationMedical EducationScience EducationNarrative StudiesNature Of SciencePedagogyCase Study ResearchCase-based LearningMoral EducationGraduate CurriculumPedagogical UsesStorytellingUndergraduate Curriculum
Who doesn't like a good story? Teachers and parsons have used them to perk up their students and parishioners from time immemorial. Stones capture our attention, entertain us. stir our emotions, and expand our visions. Preachers use them for moral persuasion, comedians to tickle our lunny bone, and teachers as exemplars of good practice. The formal use of stones, called case studies, was introduced into Harvard University s law and business schools around a hundred years ago. Professor Charles I. Gragg extolled the virtues of the method sixty years ago in an article with an eye-catching title (to which this article s title pays homage), Because Wisdom (Can't Be Told. The title itself emphasizes the truism that simply lecturing students about a subject hardly ensures that they will remember amthing at all. The medical profession has known this for a long time. They have always used case studies to instruct their interns and residents with war stories, but the whole process wasn't formalized until thirty years ago, when McMaster University introduced the storytelling method, Problem Based Learning (PBL). into their medical school curriculum. Today case-based teaching has gone well beyond these graduate programs, especially in science and engineering. Two groups are arguably responsible for most of the excitement: the University of Delaware and the University at Buffalo-The State University at New York (SUNY). Both institutions have been the grateful recipients of generous grant support from the U.S. Department of Education, the Pew Charitable Trusts, and the National Science Foundation (NSF) for the past decade. The University of Delaware hits enthusiastically promulgated the PBL approach across the country and urged its adoption in every undergraduate discipline on campus. We at the University at Buffalo have been less eclectic. Mindful of the surveys that claim that most U.S. citizens are scientifically illiterate and that there is a disastrous loss of student interest in science throughout the secondary and college years, we have focused our attention on these problems. And we personally know some shocking statistics about introductory science classrooms at large universities. It is not uncommon for 30 to 40 percent of the students to receive Fs, Ds, or withdraw. This statistic seems to be true regardless of the skill of the instructor. Not surprisingly, attendance in these courses is also terrible. Even fine lecturers often end up with less than 50 percent of their class present. Can this situation be completely the result of the immaturity of the students, their lack of motivation, or the fact that many of them work long hours outside of the classroom? Is none of it our fault? Many faculty seem to act as if it is beyond their control. But is that true? I am especially fond of the sentences uttered by the Swiss developmental psychologist Jean Piaget: At one time every teacher ought to have been an animal trainer. When the animal doesn't do the trick, you don't blame the animal. You blame the trainer. And change the method of training, of course. Changing the Training There are lots of ideas about how to change the training. Most of them involve active learning-getting students to do something rather than passively receiving wisdom. Our approach at the University at Buffalo has been to capitalize on the inherent interest that is sparked by stories. Not simply for entertainment but stories with an educational message. Of course, the can be told in a number of different ways: through lectures (such as when I give a lecture in the first person as Charles Darwin); as a written story, video, or movie with a discussion following-the method treasured by business and law schools; as a PBL problem, which can be presented to small groups of students; or even through one-on-one discussion, with a professor sitting on one end of the log and the student on the other. …