Mission or Empire, Word or Sword? The Human Capital Legacy in Postcolonial Democratic Development

Tomila V. Lankina, Lullit Getachew

American Journal of Political Science · 2011 · 140 citations · 79 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Former colonies differ in democratic outcomes, yet scholarship has largely focused on institutional legacies of colonial powers, overlooking the distinct roles of actors such as missionaries and the nation‑state lens of the British Empire’s influence. This study isolates the democratic effects of Christian missionaries from those of colonial powers by adopting a subnational approach. Missionaries promoted education, which fostered social inclusivity and reform movements, and the authors constructed district‑level datasets for India to conduct panel analyses of literacy and democracy variations supported by case studies. The results contest the primacy of British institutional legacies and instead underscore the significant human‑capital legacy of missionaries in shaping postcolonial democracy.

Abstract

Why are some former colonies more democratic than others? The British Empire has been singled out in the debates on colonialism for its benign influence on democracy. Much of this scholarship has focused on colonialism's institutional legacies; has neglected to distinguish among the actors associated with colonialism; and has been nation‐state focused. Our subnational approach allows us to isolate the democracy effects of key actors operating in colonial domains—Christian missionaries—from those of colonial powers. Missionaries influenced democracy by promoting education; education promoted social inclusivity and spurred social reform movements. To make our case, we constructed colonial and postcolonial period district datasets of India and conducted panel analysis of literacy and democracy variations backed by case studies. The findings challenge the conventional wisdom of the centrality of the effects of British institutions on democracy, instead also highlighting the missionaries’ human capital legacies.

References

79