Choice Reviews Online · 1989 · 1.2K citations · 0 references
Social SciencesSocial PsychologySociologyEveryday Life StudiesSelfSocial PhilosophyPolitical IdeologyStandpoint TheoryScientific Understanding
Ideological Dilemmas offers a novel perspective on everyday thinking, highlighting how contradictory strands in ideology and common sense shape how people make sense of their lives, and bridges sociology and social psychology. The authors argue that ideological dilemmas enable rather than inhibit thinking, helping individuals reflect meaningfully on themselves and the world. They analyze discourse in key contexts such as education, medical care, race, and gender to identify common ideological themes and tensions between equality/authority, freedom/necessity, and individuality/collectivity. The study finds that contradictions between ideological themes repeatedly surface in respondents’ arguments, reminding sociologists that ideology is reproduced through individual thought and urging social psychologists to acknowledge its ideological nature.
A major contribution to the social scientific understanding of how people make sense of their lives, Ideological Dilemmas presents an illuminating new approach to the study of everyday thinking. Contradictory strands abound within both ideology and common sense. In contrast to many modern theorists, the authors see these dilemmas of ideology as enabling, rather than inhibiting: thinking about them helps people to think meaningfully about themselves and the world. The dilemmas within ideology and their effects on thinking are explored through the analysis of what people say in specific key situations: education, medical care, race and gender. The authors identify common ideological themes running through the common-sense discourses they analyse. They highlight the tensions between themes of equality and authority, freedom and necessity, individuality and collectivity. Time and again, the contradictions between these ideological themes crop up as respondents argue and puzzle over their social worlds. Written with refreshing clarity, the discussion cuts across the boundary which often separates sociology from social psychology. Sociologists are reminded that the reproduction of ideology involves individual processes of thinking; social psychologists are urged to recognize the ideological nature of thought.