Informal Logic · 2005 · 37 citations · 8 references
HumanitiesPhilosophyConflict AnalysisConflict ResolutionLegal ReasoningArgument ConstructionArgumentationArgumentation TheoryDispute ResolutionInformal LogicArgument Systems
Argument-giving reasons for a view-is our model of rational dispute resolution. Fogelin (1985) suggests that certain "deep" disagreements cannot be resolved in this way because features of their context "undercut the conditions essential to arguing" (p. 5). In this paper we add some detail to Fogelin's treatment of intractable disagreements. In doing so we distinguish between his relatively modest claim that some disputes cannot be resolved through argument and his more radical claim that such disputes are beyond rational resolution. This distinction, along with some ofthe detail we add to Fogelin's treatment, sheds some useful light on the project of informal logic.
8
Must we mean what we say?<sup>1</sup>
Stanley Cavell · Inquiry · 1958 · 488 citations
The Logic of Deep Disagreements
Robert J. Fogelin · Informal Logic · 2005 · 191 citations · Full text
Tower of Babel: the evidence against the new creationism
Choice Reviews Online · 1999 · 190 citations
Argument and Deliberation: A Plea for Understanding
Larry Wright · The Journal of Philosophy · 1995 · 74 citations