Stanford Law Review · 2005 · 21 citations · 0 references
LawConstitutional LawCriminal LawCriminal ProcedureFreedom Of ExpressionSubstantive Criminal LawCriminal JusticeCriminal PenaltiesPunishment TheorySentencing PrinciplesSentencing ProcedureParity In SentencingRacial Disparities In PunishmentRacial Disparity In SentencingSentencing Theory
Stark theoretical and ideological differences abound regarding the purpose of punishment, the circumstances under which it can be imposed, and who holds the ultimate authority to impose it. Because these age-old debates are not likely to be resolved in the near future, should Congress decide to address the issue of federal sentencing again, it ought to begin its inquiry from a point of consensus. Are there first principles of punishment and sentencing on which most Americans can agree? What lessons have we learned from the last thirty