Effectively Maintained Inequality: Education Transitions, Track Mobility, and Social Background Effects

Samuel R. Lucas

American Journal of Sociology · 2001 · 1.7K citations · 42 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Educational attainment research indicates that later education transitions are associated with lower social background effects, though explanations range from life‑course changes to statistical artifacts and assumptions of myopic agents. The article proposes a general explanation for social background‑related inequality and addresses criticisms by framing educational transitions as students’ movement through a stratified curriculum. Students select their stratum—potentially dropping out—based on their most recent salient performance, and time‑varying performance measures predict track placement and school continuation, supporting the validity of the educational transitions approach and indicating substantial social background effects even for nearly universal transitions. Results are consistent with the perspective of effectively maintained inequality, confirming that substantial social background effects persist even for nearly universal transitions.

Abstract

This article proposes a general explanation for social background‐related inequality. Educational attainment research indicates that the later an education transition, the lower the social background effect. While some suggest life course changes in the parent‐child relationship or between‐family competition explain this pattern, others contend the result is a statistical artifact, and that the analytic strategy presupposes agents are irrationally myopic. This article addresses these criticisms by framing educational transitions in terms of students' movement through the stratified curriculum. Students select their stratum, one of which is dropping out. To make these choices, they consider their most recent salient performance. Using time‐varying performance measures to predict students' track placement/school continuation sustains the validity of the educational transitions approach and suggests substantively important social background effects even for nearly universal transitions. Results are consistent with the general perspective termed effectively maintained inequality.

References

42