Two-Moment Decision Models and Expected Utility Maximization

Jack Meyer

American Economic Review · 2016 · 609 citations · 11 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Two‑moment decision models are consistent with expected utility maximization only under certain restrictions, and the literature compares mean‑standard deviation and expected‑utility approaches to identify conditions for equivalence. The paper identifies a sufficient restriction that guarantees consistency between two‑moment decision models and expected utility maximization and verifies its validity across many economic models. The study demonstrates that the identified restriction ensures consistency and derives its implications for economic analysis. Space does not.

Abstract

Two-moment decision models are consistent with expected utility maximization only if the choice set or the agent's preferences are restricted. This paper identifies a restriction which is sufficient to ensure this consistency and confirms that it holds in many economic models. The implications for economic analysis are then derived. Two different approaches to representing an agent's preferences over strategies yielding random payoffs are in wide use. Under the mean-standard deviation (MS) approach, the agent is assumed to rank the alternatives according to the value of some function defined over the first two moments of the random payoff, while the expected utility (EU) criterion assumes that the expected value of some utility function defined over payoffs is used instead. The fact that there are these two competing approaches has generated a considerable literature. Some authors are concerned with the advantages and disadvantages of each, while others deal with conditions under which the potentially different approaches would yield the same results, or at least approximately so. Space does not

References

11