Valuation accuracy: A contribution to the debate

Colin Lizieri, Piers Venmore‐Rowland

Journal of Property Research · 1991 · 53 citations · 5 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Valuation accuracy is a critical issue for property professionals and investment analysts, and recent academic debate has focused on its methodological assessment. This paper investigates three key areas related to valuation accuracy. The authors examine methodological challenges in linking prior valuations to transaction prices, critically review previous empirical studies and academic critiques, and analyze a sample of property transactions to assess the relationship with prior valuations. They conclude that the empirical investigation is fraught with methodological problems, and while some valuation error exists, significant bias is unlikely.

Abstract

Summary The issue of valuation accuracy is important for property professionals and investment analysts. The issue of accuracy and the methodology for assessing it has been the subject of recent academic research and debate. This paper focuses on three main areas related to the topic of valuation accuracy. Firstly, it examines some of the methodological problems and concerns of attempting to assess the relationship between prior valuations and subsequent transaction prices. Secondly, previous empirical research on this topic is critically examined. Academic critiques of previous empirical research are reviewed. Finally, a sample of property transactions is analysed in order to assess the relationship with the previous valuation. It is concluded that the empirical investigation of valuation accuracy is fraught with methodological problems. Moreover, it is tentatively concluded that there is likely to be an element of error in the valuation process but that it is unlikely that valuation bias is significant.

References

5