Chemia Analityczna · 2009 · 15 citations · 0 references
AgricultureFood ScienceFood AnalysisFood ChemistrySpectroscopic AnalysisColor AnalysisColor ChemistryInstrumental AnalysisBee ProductsHoney Authenticity AssessmentLimitsQuantification LimitsSensitivity
In this study HPLC technique and classical spectrophotometric Winkler approach for determination of 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF) in natural honey were compared with respect to recovery, precision and sensitivity (detection and quantification limits). HMF content was determined in 15 types of natural honey using both investigated methods. Six honey samples were purchased in retail outlets in the Gdansk-Gdynia-Sopot Tri-City area, and 9 samples were obtained directly from six beekeepers. Significance of differences between HMF levels in honeys determined by both methods was estimated with the use of the Student's t-test (α = 0.05). In each analyzed honey sample, HMF content determined by the Winkler method was statistically significantly higher than that obtained by the HPLC technique. The above result can most likely be attributed to the presence of aldehydes other than HMF, furan derivatives, that undergo a color reaction with p-toluidine and barbituric acid in honey. HMF content in the analyzed samples determined by HPLC was in the range 180.12-4979.63 μg/100 g of honey. In three samples HMF level exceeded the allowable limit and was above 4000 μg/ 100 g of honey. Owing to higher sensitivity and repeatability of HPLC, non-specificity of the Winkler approach, and carcinogenicity of p-toluidine used in the determination process, HPLC seems to be a superior method for determination of HMF content in natural honey.